Stop comparing gone girl and the girl on the train. Even as gone girl grows truly twisted and wild, it says smart things about how tenuous power relations are between men and women, and how often couples are at the mercy of forces beyond their control. The hunger games book to film differences the hunger games. Since the wild success of gone girl and the girl on the train, girls or women referred to as girls are popping up everywhere in suspense stories, and theres no end in sight.
Major differences between the gone girl book and movie. It was published by crown publishing group in june 2012. Nick and amy hate and love each other like most couples, but more important. It is also fun to see if there is a book that is selected many times last year crawdads and michelle obamas book becoming were featured frequently. This burgeoning genre is called up lit, which stands for uplifting literature. As with gone girl, it seems readers cant resist a dark take on modern matrimony. Then earlier this year, in an interview with ew about the movie adaptation. I was a little taken aback, taylor said of the violent ending. Sep 16, 2018 well, in 1908, or the turn of the century, jung began to see a significant difference between his mentors psychology and his own.
Paula hawkins the girl on the train and gillian flynns gone girl do share a zeitgeisty focus on the unlikable woman and a dark view of suburbia. Jun 19, 2014 on the face of it, the movie and the book have much in common. The first half of the book was great, she built up the suspense masterfully. Whats the difference between the girl on the train the book and the girl on the train the movie.
Gone girl uses classic screenwriting techniques to tell its twisty, modern noir story. Nov 21, 2012 there is a lot of suffering in life of pi and merely a few moments of beauty and glorylike in the lightning storm that appears in both the book and the film. As expected, there are some differences between hawkins book. One of the most important differences between the book and the film is the.
Despite the fact that flynn wrote the screenplay for david finchers new film, there are a few small plot twists that didnt make the cut. David andrew leo fincher was born on august 28, 1962, in denver, colorado, the son of claire mae nee boettcher, a mental health nurse from south dakota who worked in drug addiction programs, and howard kelly jack fincher, an author from oklahoma who worked as a reporter and bureau chief for life magazine. Hawkins spoke with time about taking a risk by using an unlikable narrator, her hitchcockian inspirations and why maybe folks shouldnt be lumping girl on the train and gone girl. The film version of gone girl, which hit theaters this weekend, follows the novel closely. A drunken confession by nick at the bar to a reporter, where he confesses that he loves his wife 3. Soon to be a major motion picture starring nicole kidman, fans of the girl on the train and gone girl will love the silent wife i gobbled it down in one sitting. Rachel watson is a 33yearold alcoholic, reeling from the end of her marriage to tom, who left her for another woman, anna boyd. This was a bit of a sideswipe for me, as id planned to discuss the differences between the two endings of gone girl and determine whether the new, cinematic conclusion worked better, worse, or the same as that of the. The novel by chuck palahniuk won a some awards, but the film adaptation in 1999 is what put the. And yes, despite rumors to the contrary, the film does having the same ending as the novel. Discover more details about the lion true story by watching the saroo brierley documentary and interviews below. Gone girl study guide contains a biography of gillian flynn, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. For one, jung deemphasized sexual development and instead began focusing on the collective unconscious which is the part of the unconscious that consisted of ideas and memories that came from ancestors. Gone girl dont underestimate the screenwriter youtube.
Girl on the train author shoots down gone girl comparisons. The following are noted differences between the original the hunger games book and the hunger games film. Here are all the big differences between gone girl the book. It was one of those books i felt kind of like showering after i finished reading it to. Gone girl and the girl on the train have some similarities, but their differences are greater but the stories are similar, sort of. Here are all the big differences between gone girl the. The 2017 entry in this craze is jp delaneys highly touted the girl before, which plays out like a cross between a hitchcock movie and an episode of the terrific british technothriller series black mirror. How emily blunts girl on the train ended up so different from the book. Before signing on to direct this weekends adaptation of the girl on the train, tate. Despite the fact that flynn wrote the screenplay for david finchers new film, there are a. The story unfolds with backtoback chapters for most of the novel depicting both jane in the present and emma in the past.
In gone girl, i found both main characters despicable. The elephant in the room throughout all of this is the girl on the train s twisted sister, gone girl. The first trailer for the girl on the train was obviously calculated to fuel the comparison. Maybe thats the difference between who likes the ending and who doesnt. Gillian flynn reflects on gone girl legacy, rise of anti. The novel debuted in the number one spot on the new york times fiction best sellers of 2015 list print and e book dated 1 february 2015, 2 and remained. In the end, megans ashes are scattered beside her babys grave in the woods. The film concludes with amy and nick going on television to announce amys pregnancy, as opposed.
Unfortunately for taylor, the comparison does not favor train, with some. Although i hated anna in train, i sympathized with rachel and somewhat with megan. Differences between the book and the movie posted on 5 august 12 by gwenamon just in case you glossed over the title of. The books turnedmovies have been compared lately after the success of gone girl and the upcoming release of the girl on the train, but in fact, the differences are more apparent than the. The movie mandys beginning middle and ending decoded. Lake staying on the train because she is good at helping people would be a terrible ending. Per a 2017 article in the guardian, publishers say the trend started in response to the current climate leading for.
Their similarities are clear, and girl on the train tries its best to turn the david fincher. Ill add the conclusion to the end of that sentence as well. Oct 08, 2014 the book version of gone girl, so ive heard, is a crime novel. The girl on the train 2016 the girl on the train 2016. Spoilers for gone girl and the girl on the train follow. Being the cool girl means i am a hot, brilliant, funny woman who adores football, poker, dirty jokes, and burping, who plays video games, drinks cheap beer, loves threesomes and anal sex, and jams hot dogs and hamburgers into her mouth like shes hosting the worlds biggest culinary gang bang while. An anonymous girl audiobook by greer hendricks, sarah. Aug 18, 2018 the orphan train by christina baker kline moves back and forth between two stories that of a young orphan girl in the early twentieth century and that of a teenager in the modernday foster care system. Gone girl is an example of mystery, suspense, and crime genres. The film concludes with amy and nick going on television to announce amys pregnancy, as opposed to in the book, when its a more private matter. The woman in the window and 2015s girl on the train by paula hawkins. The film stars ben affleck, rosamund pike, neil patrick harris, and tyler perry. The main thing that remains of whites story in the film is the ending.
Amelia could leave the train, content with the knowledge that he is gone for good, but the same can never be said for jesse, as he knows that lake is essentially trapped in a living hell, and could return home with him. Heres how gillian flynn defended the ending of gone girl. However it also is a failure on its own terms as an overall film, one doesnt even need to have read the book or have knowledge of it to still. Gone girls ending is different from the book in these. Dec 24, 2015 president obama and amazon named lauren groffs wordofmouth sensation fates and furies as their book of the year. So it makes sense that tate taylors adaptation of the novel would weather some. One clue involving nicks trip to hannibal where he would occasionally go with amy and later andy. Lets call it the gonegirlonatrain school of highanxiety thriller. Its just that there are so many stories to choose from, which you already know if you, like millions of other readers, rapidly inhaled novels like gone girl and the girl on the train over the. Now that the discarded footage of gone with the wind no longer exists, it is impossible to know exactly what was lost in the cutting room between the first mgm screening and the final version. Oct 07, 2016 how emily blunts girl on the train ended up so different from the book. There are spoilers for both the book and film versions of gone girl ahead.
Is gone girls movie ending different from the book. At first glance, it seems like it would be pretty obvious whats up with gone girl s titleits a book about a girl who disappears, which means shes, well, gone. How emily blunts girl on the train ended up so different from the. Oct 03, 2014 here are all the big differences between gone girl the book and gone girl the movie.
While in essence, the plot is not the same, there are many similarities between the two, not least in the way both movies examine the relationships between men. Maureen corrigan, who is the book critic for the npr program, fresh air. What are the differences between gone girl the movie and gone girl the novel. Maybe thats true, but theres more to flynns title choice than meets the eyeand in a lot of ways, its actually describing amy herself. Gone girl is a 2014 american psychological thriller film directed by david fincher and with a screenplay by gillian flynn based on her 2012 novel of the same title. While the book ends with some hope, its hardly this upbeat. If you dont want to know what happens in either film or book. The orphan train by christina baker kline questions. Oct 06, 2014 the differences between the ending of gone girl, the film, and gone girl, the book, are miniscule. Gone girl revamps gender stereotypes for the worse. The girl on the train chugs into theaters on friday, october 7.
Jul 20, 2017 strange but true, by john searles searles 2004 novel has a premise just screaming for spoilers. You may want to understand the explanation of hell. Unfortunately, i found the characters in an anonymous girl to be rather flat, and the plot seemed to involve many repetitions of the same basic scenario. What gone girl and the girl on the train have wrought the. After her disappearance, the story of megans baby spurs another round of headlines. Read the girl who got rattled, the stewart edward white. In the book, at least desis mother goes to the police, hysterical, saying that amy killed her son even though shes whisked away, theres the faint hope that maybe the case is reopened. In fact, the only truly unreliable narrator in the book is tom, your friendly. Gillian flynn reflects on the popularity and legacy of her 2012 novel gone girl. Earlier this year, many fans of gillian flynns 2012 thriller gone girl were dismayed to learn that the author had changed the storys ending for the film adaptation. This video examines three of the techniques used by screenwriter gillian flynn to see how and why they work.
The girl on the train was the mustread thriller of 2015, and for the most part, the movie sticks to the book. Jodi and todd are at a bad place in their marriage. Through her two ultimately unreliable narrators, flynn masterfully weaves the slow trickle of critical details with 90degree plot turns. Minor tweaks aside, nick still chooses amy, and amy chooses nick. Differences between the girl on the train book vs movie page 1.
Ben affleck, in interviews, described it as a complete rewrite of the story s third act. What are the major differences between the book gone girl. Gone girl movie plot ending, explained the cinemaholic. However, there are at least five big differences that youll notice even if its. The novel soon made the new york times best seller list. Gone girl is a story of the trials and tribulations that a couple, nick and amy dunne go through in their young marriage. San francisco chronicle gillian flynns barbed and brilliant gone girl has two deceitful, disturbing, irresistible narrators and a plot that twists so many times youll be dizzy. The girl on the train author on if its the next gone. How emily blunts girl on the train ended up so different. Psychological suspense is one of my favorite genres, and the wife between us is one of my favorite books. As entertainment weekly reported in january, director david fincher quoted ben affleck as saying, this is a whole new third act. The girl on the train focuses on a real murder, while gone girl does not. Those who do find themselves having somewhat of an allegiance or. David finchers gone girl has a different third act than.
The girl on the train by paula hawkins is a surprise hit debut thriller thats gathering gone girl type of buzz. Here we discuss the difference between angels and demons, looking into their origin, intentions and actions. As if that werent enough, flynn has created a genuinely creepy villain you dont see coming. What gone girl and the girl on the train have wrought. The movie is a commentary on the roles we all play to function in society, that image that we create for ourselves that determines how we will be treated by the community. The girl on the train is a 2015 psychological thriller novel by british author paula hawkins that gives narratives from three different women about relationship troubles and binge drinking. Its pretty easy to become hooked on movie quotes and lines, so to start you off on your exploration an a z manual of all kinds of quotes and lines from a variety of movies have been created here for you, some memorable and some not so memorable. But dont be surprised to see some changes in the onscreen adaptation of the beloved gillian flynn book. Both gone girl and the girl on the train have multiple narrators. The differences between the ending of gone girl, the film, and gone girl, the book, are miniscule. Here are all the big differences between gone girl the book and gone girl the movie. Men always say that as the defining compliment, dont they. The girl on the train is a 2015 psychological thriller novel by british author paula hawkins that.
Is the girl on the train movie like the gone girl movie. The girl on the train is an adaptation of paula hawkins bestselling novel, and it has drawn comparisons with another successful book to film adaptation. In comparison the girl on the train is down there among the most underwhelming book tofilm adaptations, with everything that made the book so good being completely lost in translation in the film. Fasterpaced, more traditional mystery, more gripping in my. This post contains spoilers for the book and film versions of the girl on the train. Earlier this year, many fans of gillian flynns 2012 thriller gone girl were dismayed to learn that the author had changed the storys ending for. Timely, poignant and emotionally rich, gone girl will peel away your comfort levels even as you root for its protagonistsdespite your best intuition. The novels suspense comes from the main character, nick dunne, and whether he is involved in the disappearance of his wife. Book journey continuing adventures of a true bookaholic. As gone girl rolled through production, there was talk about director david fincher and screenwriter gillian flynn tinkering with and possibly changing the ending to the authors bestselling novel. With all things breezy at first, life eventually hits hard and things spiral out of control as problems in their marriage and individual selves surface. Why fates and furies was this years most talkedabout novel. As the novels author suzanne collins was also one of the screenwriters as well as one of the films producers, it should be inferred that all changes were approved by her. Apr 09, 2015 before brad pitt barked out the first rule of fight club, people were talking about fight club.
I found myself not even caring what happened to the characters after a while, i kept reading expecting it to. The biggest differences between the gone girl movie. I hated gone girl in part because i figured out the ending much too quickly. Victoria lank to me, the main difference between gone girl and the girl on the train was that in the girl on the train, some of the characters are more sympathetic as others have stated.
886 572 999 984 1302 247 1282 1160 1248 647 1433 191 1229 869 662 692 539 168 1209 498 1573 1641 881 1344 588 220 505 1446 1190 1307 797 458 59 1175 1452 868 490 675